Leftover Thanksgiving Pizza Recipes and Ideas

Somewhere between Friday naps and Black Friday deals, the leftovers start whispering from the fridge. Turkey. Stuffing. And grandma’s mashed potatoes that could double as mortar. You’ve already made one too many sandwiches. Time for something different. Hungry Howie’s says: turn those Thanksgiving extras into something really tasty.

From Italian Herb Crust masterpieces to oven-baked subs stacked with turkey and cheddar, there’s no rule that says Thanksgiving leftovers have to be boring. Consider this your guide to reclaiming the fridge with fresh flavor, and maybe a side of Cinnamon Howie Bread® while you’re at it.

Fun Facts About Eating Pizza During Thanksgiving

Even with all that turkey, Americans still can’t quit pizza. According to food delivery data, the day before Thanksgiving is one of the biggest pizza delivery nights of the year. It makes sense, no one wants to dirty the kitchen or make a big meal before the big day. 

And once the main feast is over, pizza becomes the unofficial meal of recovery. Friendsgiving parties? Pizza. Thanksgiving college football games? Pizza. Midnight snack after too much pie? You guessed it. In fact, ordering pizza after Thanksgiving has become a low-key tradition for families who are officially “done cooking” but not done eating.

So, if you’re thinking of swapping the leftovers for a fresh pizza pie, you’re not alone. We think Hungry Howie’s pizza delivery is basically a post-holiday survival move.

Thanksgiving Leftover Pizza Ideas

Call it Thanksgiving pizza or call it genius, either way, you’re about to win dinner. Leftover turkey makes a surprisingly good pizza topping, especially when it teams up with base of mozzarella, and heck, maybe some drizzle of gravy. Try it on our Italian Herb Crust to really play up those savory holiday flavors.

• Turkey & Cranberry Remix - Shred leftover turkey over a Butter Crust cheese pizza with mozzarella. Add a swirl of tangy BBQ sauce or a side of your own cranberry sauce for a sweet-savory dip.
• Stuffing Supreme - Add small bites of stuffing to a Garlic Herb Crust pie with shredded turkey, onions, and a light drizzle of gravy for an all-in holiday remix.
• Veggie Comeback - Have leftover roasted vegetables? Pile them onto your favorite Veggie Pizza or create your own mix using our Build Your Own Pizza option with extra mozzarella and Italian seasoning.

Or just skip the DIY and order one of your favorites from Hungry Howie’s. It’s the easiest way to turn post-Thanksgiving fatigue into pizza-night success.

Upgrade Your Salads

Salads don’t have to sit on the sidelines this weekend. Chop up some leftover turkey and toss it into a Chef Salad from Hungry Howie’s. The protein boost makes it lunch-worthy, especially when topped with Italian or ranch dressing.

And if you’re working through that “too much gravy” guilt, this is your fresh start. A little crunchy lettuce never hurt anybody.

Baked Sub Combinations

You’ve had the turkey sandwich, but not like this. Load turkey and cheddar onto an Oven-Baked Sub, then add BBQ sauce or ranch for a tangy twist. It’s comfort food with a toasted edge, no Tupperware needed.

Want to go next level? Add bacon and a drizzle of honey mustard. It’s giving “leftovers, but delicious.”

Dessert Combinations to Try

There’s always room for dessert, especially when Cinnamon Howie Bread® is on the table. Try it with leftover whipped cream or a scoop of vanilla ice cream for instant dessert magic.

And if you managed to snag a loaf of Pumpkin Spice Bread (our limited-time favorite), drizzle it with caramel or chocolate sauce for an easy sweet hack that feels straight out of a bakery window. Leftovers never tasted this good.

Order Hungry Howie’s to Help with Your Leftover Thanksgiving Food

At some point, even the most creative cook hits a wall. When that happens, let Hungry Howie’s take it from here. Skip the dishes and order pizza delivery straight to your door. Choose from your favorite Flavored Crust® options, like Garlic Herb, Butter Cheese, or Ranch, to complement your holiday mood.

Whether you’re hosting family for one more round or just avoiding the oven, order online for takeout or delivery and enjoy hot, fresh pizza that makes any leftover feel like a new meal.

Thanksgiving might be about gratitude, but the weekend after? That’s about making smart food choices, and pizza’s a pretty brilliant one. So, raid the fridge, remix those flavors, and let Hungry Howie’s help you turn “leftover” into something worth celebrating.